Choosing the right engine oil isn’t just about the brand—it’s about keeping your car running smoothly in real U.S. driving conditions. I’ve tested Amsoil and Valvoline in stop-and-go traffic, long highway drives, and extreme weather. The differences? Worth knowing.
Whether you drive a Ford F-150 in Arizona’s heat or a Toyota Camry in a New England winter, oil choice matters. It affects engine life, fuel efficiency, and performance. In this review, I’ll break down which oil works best for different cars, driving styles, and climates—so you can pick the right one for your ride.
Table of Contents
Is AMSOIL Good Oil?
When it comes to synthetic motor oil, AMSOIL has a strong reputation. But is it worth the hype? From my experience, yes—if you want top-tier engine protection and longer oil change intervals.
I’ve used AMSOIL Signature Series 0W-20 in my turbocharged Honda Accord. I also tested AMSOIL Small Engine Oil in my lawnmower. The results? Smoother startups in cold weather, better gas mileage, and less engine noise.
The 25,000-mile oil change claim is bold. I stick to 10,000-15,000 miles for peace of mind.
Why AMSOIL Stands Out
- Great Engine Protection – Prevents metal-on-metal wear, extending engine life.
- Longer Oil Change Intervals – Some AMSOIL oils last up to 25,000 miles.
- Better Fuel Efficiency – Reduces friction, saving gas over time.
- Cold-Weather Performance – Flows well in freezing temps for easier startups.
- Less Oil Consumption – Less evaporation means fewer top-offs.
- Works for Many Engines – Gas, diesel, motorcycles, and small engines.
Downsides
- Costs More – It’s pricier than brands like Mobil 1 or Valvoline.
- Not in Every Store – Mostly sold online or through dealers.
- Not Always Necessary – If you drive short trips and change oil often, it may not be worth the extra cost.
My Take
AMSOIL is best for drivers who want maximum engine protection and long oil change intervals. It’s great for turbocharged, high-mileage, or performance vehicles. It also shines in extreme weather.
But if you drive a basic car and stick to 5,000-mile oil changes, you might not see a big benefit over cheaper brands. Also, check availability before committing, since it’s not always in stores.
If you want one of the best synthetic motor oils, AMSOIL is a solid investment in your engine’s health.
👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿
Is Valvoline Good Oil?
If you’re wondering whether Valvoline is a good motor oil, the short answer is yes. And here’s why.
Valvoline has been around for over 150 years. It’s a trusted name among car owners and mechanics alike. But does it hold up in real-world driving?
I’ve used Valvoline in both an older Honda Accord and a newer Ford F-150. The results? Smooth engine performance, low noise, and no unusual oil loss—even on long road trips in Arizona’s heat.
Why I Like Valvoline
- Great Engine Protection – Helps reduce wear and keep engines running smoothly.
- Many Options – Full synthetic, synthetic blend, and conventional oil choices.
- Good for High-Mileage Cars – The High Mileage Blend helps reduce leaks and sludge.
- Affordable – Costs less than Mobil 1 while offering solid performance.
- Easy to Find – Available at auto shops, Walmart, and quick-lube stations.
What Could Be Better
- Not the Best for Extreme Heat or Racing – Amsoil or Royal Purple might be better for high-stress conditions.
- Synthetic Blend vs. Full Synthetic Confusion – Some bottles look similar, so check the label.
- Slightly Shorter Oil Change Intervals – May break down faster than premium brands under heavy towing or high RPMs.
My Take
Valvoline is a great choice for everyday drivers, high-mileage vehicles, and budget-conscious car owners. It works well for gas engines, hybrids, and even turbocharged cars.
However, if you tow heavy loads, drive in extreme cold, or race, you might want a premium oil. But for daily commutes and long trips, Valvoline is reliable, affordable, and easy to find.
Would I recommend it? Absolutely—if you want a well-tested, cost-effective oil that gets the job done.
👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿
Amsoil vs Valvoline: Which One is Better for Your Car?
I’ve used both Amsoil and Valvoline in different cars over the years. If you’re trying to decide which one is right for you, I’ll break it down in a simple way.
Amsoil lasts longer and handles extreme conditions well. Valvoline is affordable and does a solid job for everyday driving. But there’s more to it than that. Let’s compare them side by side.
Viscosity: How Well Do They Flow?
Viscosity matters. It affects how your oil flows in the cold and how well it holds up in the heat.
| Aspect | Amsoil | Valvoline |
| Cold Start Flow | Super smooth in freezing temps. | A little thick when it’s really cold. |
| High-Temp Stability | Stays strong in extreme heat. | Thins out a little over time. |
| Viscosity Options | Many choices for different engines. | Standard options, but not as many. |
Rating: Amsoil: 9/10 | Valvoline: 7.5/10
Oil Type: Which One Works for Your Car?
Amsoil focuses on synthetic oils that last longer. Valvoline gives you more budget-friendly options.
| Oil Type | Amsoil | Valvoline |
| Full Synthetic | Top-tier protection, lasts longer. | Good quality, but shorter lifespan. |
| Synthetic Blend | High performance, better than most blends. | Affordable and solid for daily driving. |
| Conventional | Hard to find (mostly synthetic). | Works for older cars, but needs more changes. |
Rating: Amsoil: 9.5/10 | Valvoline: 8/10
Additives: Do They Keep Your Engine Clean?
Good additives prevent wear, reduce sludge, and protect your engine.
| Additive | Amsoil | Valvoline |
| Detergents | Keeps the engine super clean. | Works well but needs more frequent changes. |
| Anti-Wear Agents | Great for reducing metal wear. | Decent, but not as long-lasting. |
| Friction Modifiers | Helps with fuel efficiency. | Doesn’t do much for MPG. |
Rating: Amsoil: 9/10 | Valvoline: 7.5/10
👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿
Engine Protection: Which One Keeps Your Engine Running Longer?
Protection is key. Both oils help, but Amsoil holds up better over time.
| Protection | Amsoil | Valvoline |
| Wear Prevention | Strong additives protect longer. | Good but breaks down faster. |
| Sludge Control | Stops buildup and deposits. | Needs more frequent changes to stay clean. |
| Longevity | Can last up to 25,000 miles. | Usually needs a change at 5,000–7,500 miles. |
Rating: Amsoil: 9.5/10 | Valvoline: 7.5/10
Fuel Efficiency: Does It Help Your MPG?
A good oil should help your engine run smoothly and efficiently.
| Factor | Amsoil | Valvoline |
| MPG Boost | Helps slightly due to reduced friction. | No real difference in fuel economy. |
| Smoothness | Engine feels smoother. | Works fine, but nothing special. |
| Good for High Mileage? | Great for older cars, keeps them running strong. | Works, but not as effective long-term. |
Rating: Amsoil: 8.5/10 | Valvoline: 7/10
Temperature Performance: How Well Do They Handle Heat and Cold?
Weather plays a big role in how oil performs.
| Condition | Amsoil | Valvoline |
| Cold Start | Flows quickly in freezing temps. | Thicker, takes longer to warm up. |
| Hot Weather | Holds up well in extreme heat. | Breaks down a little faster. |
| Extreme Conditions | Reliable for towing and racing. | Good for daily driving, but nothing extreme. |
Rating: Amsoil: 9/10 | Valvoline: 7.5/10
Longevity: How Often Do You Need to Change It?
If you hate oil changes, Amsoil wins hands down.
| Longevity | Amsoil | Valvoline |
| Oil Change Interval | Up to 25,000 miles (with Signature Series). | Usually 5,000–7,500 miles. |
| Best for High Mileage? | Great for cars over 75K miles. | Works fine, but not as strong. |
| Extended-Drain Options? | Yes, lasts much longer. | No extended-drain products. |
Rating: Amsoil: 9.5/10 | Valvoline: 7/10
👉🏿👉🏻 Check Latest Price and Offer at Amazon 👈🏻👈🏿
Final Recommendation: Which One Should You Choose?
Go with Amsoil if you:
- Want longer oil change intervals (less hassle).
- Drive in extreme heat or cold.
- Own a high-performance or high-mileage car.
Go with Valvoline if you:
- Need a budget-friendly, reliable oil.
- Don’t mind changing oil more often.
- Drive a regular daily commuter.
Final Verdict: If you want the best performance and longest oil life, Amsoil is the winner. But if you just need a good, affordable oil for everyday use, Valvoline is a solid choice.
FAQs: Amsoil vs Valvoline
Which is better, Amsoil or Valvoline?
It depends on what you need. Amsoil lasts longer and handles extreme conditions better. Valvoline is more affordable and easier to find. Both do a great job protecting your engine.
Is Amsoil worth the higher price?
Yes, if you want longer oil change intervals and top-tier wear protection. Amsoil’s synthetic formula lasts longer, which can save you money in the long run—especially for high-mileage drivers.
Does Valvoline perform well in cold weather?
Yes! Valvoline’s full synthetic oils flow well in freezing temperatures, making cold starts easier. But if you need all-season performance, Amsoil’s high-temp stability gives it an edge.
Which oil is better for older engines?
Both brands offer high-mileage options. Amsoil’s synthetic blend helps reduce deposits and wear. Valvoline’s MaxLife is a budget-friendly choice that still provides solid protection.
How often should I change my oil with Amsoil vs Valvoline?
Amsoil lasts up to 25,000 miles, while Valvoline recommends changing it every 3,000 to 10,000 miles, depending on the oil type. Always check your car’s manual for the best interval.